View Single Post
  #4 (permalink)  
Old 21-05-2008, 14:54
churchill
Guest
 
Posts: n/a
Default Re: Advance Decision to Refuse Treatment or "Right to Die" Cards

Quote:
Originally Posted by von Clausewitz View Post
"Refuse treatment" is too open to debate. Particularly legal debate.

What does it mean? WHEN do you refuse treatment? In what circumstances? and does it take into account that you may have signed the card ten years ago, when possible treatments have WAY surpassed what was possible when you made the decision?

This is a legal minefield. I do not think they will catch on. PARTICULARLY after a few court cases have shown them to be unworkable in practice.
It's totally illegal, no one has the 'right to die', and attending doctors who have taken their hypocratic oath would be in difficulty complying, their NHS manager probably wouldn't though.
Reply With Quote